Showing posts with label Shark Identification. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Shark Identification. Show all posts

Thursday, October 10, 2019

Mystery Sharks from Myanmar?


Check out the above - click for detail.

So, what Sharks are those?
I took the pic at Black Rock way back then in 1998. Back then there was no digital = this would be a so-called "professional scan" of the 35mm Kodachrome 64 slide - and yes those would be fucking hairs!
Anyway, there was a massive El Niño that was cooking the reefs in the Indian Ocean and beyond - but the hot water there was somehow causing a freezing cold upwelling in the Andaman Sea, and we were seeing plenty of deeper water Fishes like e.g. this rather rare Pterois mombasae we found at Richelieu Rock.
Check it out, it's an awesome Fish!


In brief, we were freezing our asses but having a blast.
Richelieu Rock was pumping with the usual Whale Sharks and a whole array of unusual critters among which mating Guitarfish, Kho Bon had dozens of Zebra Sharks and the Burma Banks, the usual assemblage of Tawnies and large territorial Silvertips;  and Black Rock was overrun with Manta Rays, to the point that we decided to turn off the engine of the dinghy and use the oars for fear of hitting one. 
We put down a few fish heads and had a few Grey Reefies come nosy about, only to be scared away by these two much larger Sharks. Both females and both likely shredded by mating, they came in hot and put up a short but awesome display of strength and assertiveness, only to quickly abscond with the bait.

There was quite some debate about the species.
Ron who was obviously way more experienced thought they may have been Graceful Sharks; I was more inclined towards them being unusually large Blacktips, and actually still think they are - and if so, they would most certainly be the largest such Sharks I've ever seen as they were clearly above 2 meters long. Or could they have been large Spinners - tho if so, where are the pinnae brevis?

Thoughts?

PS - Will confirms that they're most likely Blacktips. They look identical to Australian Blacktips (C. tilstoni) who are however strictly endemic to Australia - but thank you Julia! :)
 

Friday, May 17, 2019

What Shark is this??

Notice the caudal peduncle - click for detail!

Behold!



This is from the second 15m dive at Shark Reef a few days ago. 
For once I was not diving, and the footage is courtesy of Martin who is here for his yearly Bull Shark fix. I'm being told that the Shark was curious and circled above - but with a gaggle of Bulls dominating the feed, she remained wary and never tried to join the mêlée. 

At a reported 3 meters in length, this is a big Shark.
When they first told me, they stated that she was an emaciated, sickly Bull Shark - but from the video I can instead discern that despite of the tumor and the buckled first dorsal, she is in rather good shape. I also notice the elegant sinuous way she moves, and the keel-like bulge on her caudal peduncle, both of which are not at all diagnostic of Bull Sharks, sickly or otherwise.

So what is this?
Years ago there was another mystery Shark with a similar shape of the caudal peduncle. Back then, somebody stated that it was a Dusky - but that's a Shark living off continental shelves and we are obviously on an island, so today I'm rather skeptical.

I got my thoughts but would love to hear yours.
Opinions welcome - here on the blog and not on Facebook please!


Thank you!

PS! - May, 2022: having now sadly witnessed several moribund bull sharks, I can state with absolute certainty that this is one of those - likely Lumpy who had a large tumor and was getting ever more emaciated last time I saw her. Those Bulls are real badasses and will fight, and even compete for food til the very end.


Saturday, June 30, 2018

Five-Meter GWS?

Mako vs GWS - awesome pic by Ozzie Sam. Notice how wide the caudal keel is!   
Source - click for detail

Watch.



Hmmmmm.
For what it is worth, methinks that that Shark does not move with the gravitas of a 5-meter animal but rather, like a much smaller individual; and the very pointy snout and very wide caudal keel appear more indicative of a Shortfin Mako, at least to me.

But who am I to say.
Both species inhabit the Med, with the Mako being far more common, albeit locally threatened like all Sharks there. And do re-read this post about the rather fascinating theory about the Australian origins of the Mediterranean GWS population - paper here!
But my call remains that this is a sprightly Mako of 2-2.5m.

Original FB post here, story here.

PS - Bingo: Michael Domeier here!
PPS - compare to this clip of a Mako @ approx 0:20ff!



PPPS -  and now we got ourselves some experts...

Monday, January 19, 2015

Shark Strike - Bronze Whaler?


Watch



Methinks that's a retaliating Grey Nurse!
Martin here!

JSD? Mark?

Monday, January 12, 2015

Bull Shark or GWS?


Hmmm.

Story here.
We find a lot of Bull Shark teeth, and the central ones are perfectly symmetrical like the one depicted - but those GWS do wander from the Atlantic into the Gulf, so one straying into the Bahamas is certainly a possibility. And a bite spanning all the way from the shoulders to the buttocks is very large indeed!

Opinions?
David - JSD?

H/T: Mark!

PS - Mark just sent me this pic with Bull Shark teeth (from the SRMR no less!) - not easy!


PPS - GWS confirmed?

Thursday, January 08, 2015

Mako?

This is a Spanish Mackerel - notice the position of the second dorsal and anal fins. Source.

Watch.



The comment states,
HUGE SHARK TEARS APART MAKO SHARK 
What an encounter with the shark. Some fishermen have a mako shark at the end of the fishing hook. As they are planning to get it out of water, a massive shark comes into picture and tears apart the mako shark. A really awesome footage caught on camera!

Hell, no!
To me, that looks like a Reefie nailing a Spanish Mackerel, or the like.
JSD?

Friday, December 12, 2014

Elasmobranch Field Guides - fucking awesome!

 
This is just great.
Shark References announces them as follows
New open access field guide of the Western Indian Ocean from Dave Ebert!
The present field guide is designed to assist in the identification of pelagic sharks and rays of the Western Indian Ocean that are major, moderate, or minor importance to fisheries. It encompasses the offshore, high seas portion of FAO  Fishing Area 51. 
  • FAO_Pelagic Guide-part1  here 
  • FAO_Pelagic Guide-part2  here 
  • FAO_Pelagic Guide-part3  here
  • FAO_Pelagic Guide-part4  here 
  • FAO_Pelagic Guide-part5  here
Enjoy!

Saturday, November 08, 2014

Jackass jumps on Shark!

Another Ozzie jackass - with a real Tiger!

No way!

This shit has gone viral.
But that is never a Tiger Shark - if that is Australia like reported, then that's a Tawny Nurse.
JSD?

Anyway, watch.



Friday, September 05, 2014

Shark ID - Help wanted!

These are Bulls Sharks - click for detail!

Check this out!

What are those Sharks among those Grey Reefies?
Methinks Dusky/Galapagos (but possibly Bronzie?) and.... Pigeye (!!!) - the latter because she doesn't feel like a Bull, and because I read that from C. amboinensis, the bull shark differs in its lower, less erect first dorsal fin and higher, more erect second dorsal fin. The ratio of first:second dorsal height is 3:1 or less in C. leucas, but over 3:1 in C. amboinensis.

Opinions please!
JSD - David?



Friday, May 30, 2014

Whale Shark Pups?

Source.

No they aint - hint.
Baby Whale Sharks look like this.

Source.

Like the Whale Shark, the Bowmouth Guitarfish is listed as vulnerable to extinction.

Tuesday, May 20, 2014

Large Bull Shark?

Source.

Not large, not a Bull.
Hint.



Monday, December 30, 2013

GWS?

Click for detail!

Story here.
Poppycock - that's a Dolphin!

JSD?

PS: DaSchiffman here!

Thursday, December 26, 2013

Shark ID - Field Guides!


Maybe a tad old - but they're for free!

Red Sea Guide here, Med here.
Enjoy!

Friday, October 11, 2013

Great White chomping?




Right...
Stripiest GWS on the planet!

Story here.

Tuesday, September 03, 2013

Shark Bible - fail!

Source.

Check out this pic.

That's a Sicklefin Lemon Negaprion acutidens.
And there's plenty more pictures here - notice anything?
Yes as everybody with two eyes can see, every single one of them features a dark spot on the tip of the snout. THAT, and not some equivocal falcate fins and the like is the principal physical attribute differentiating them from ordinary Lemons - and I'm yet to come across a single ID book mentioning it!
Johann - do you agree?

And this is the illustration from the bible.


Does this in any way look like that Shark?
And what about that kink in the gills - do you see anything confirming it below? And that line originating above the gills - where does it curve down to, and why doesn't the upper Shark feature it?

Source.

Not impressed!

PS - but it's still the best there is, so get it!

Sunday, August 18, 2013

The Shark Bible - review by JSD!

Fiji Bull Sharks - pic by Gary Peart- click for detail!

Finally!

The bible is out.
And JSD has penned a review hat contains a reference to the Fiji Bull Shark - so I really got no choice but post it in its entirety!
So there!
Sharks of the World: A Fully Illustrated Guide (Hardcover) 

It is not every day that a book appears that has the unmistakable authority and quality of a classic; rarer still that such a tome should be the launch publication of a new publisher. Wild Nature Press' Sharks of the World - A Fully Illustrated Guide is such a work. 

We shouldn't be surprised. 
The team at Wild Nature Press has been illustrating and designing elegant natural history books for mainstream publishers for years and has merely transferred its talents to its own publishing house. Nor did this book appear fully formed from the primordial swamp. It evolved from the Collins Field Guide: Sharks of the World of 2005 and has the same authors (Leonard Compagno and Sarah Fowler) and illustrator (Marc Dando), plus the additional taxonomic input of David Ebert. 

The evolution has been successful. 
The new book is considerably larger than the old (compare, say, a Grey Reef Shark with a full-blown Fijian Bull Shark) and this must come as a relief not only to readers who wish to feast their eyes on the endless variations-on-a-theme that are sharks, but also to the wonderfully illustrated animals themselves. Packed with musculature and movement, they are now less likely accidentally to swim off the page. Furthermore, the species described herein have grown to over 500 (there are some 90 recently named sharks). 

The book basically divides into 2 parts. 
After the foreword (by scientist John Stevens) there is a grand tour through the biology and natural history of the animals that deals with every topic you could ask for. Illustrated with occasional photographs and a great many colour drawings, as well as maps, diagrams and charts, the intricacies of shark biology as well as crucial themes such as fisheries, conservation and management, are explained. On page 59 one reaches the raison d'être of what has been: the magisterially presented description of every shark from the known knowns to the known unknowns. Each has its own entry which includes a detailed line drawing and goes on to describe size, distribution (via a map), teeth, identification, habitat, behaviour, biology and conservation status. To enrich this section the sharks are also depicted in full colour plates and also via some photographs (of living sharks). These photographs take us far beyond the usual suspects: consider the Greenland Shark (p. 157), the Caribbean Roughshark (p. 162), the Goblin Shark - I kid you not! - (p. 216), the Blackmouth Catshark (p. 347), or the Snaggletooth Shark (p. 437). 

But there is more. 
Appendices include a glossary, discussion of oceans and seas, techniques of field observation and fin identification, recommendations for further reading, a list of scientific and conservation organisations, online information sources, and index. Phew. 

Only an ignoramus would claim that sharks are not sufficiently interesting to deserve so impressive a treatment.
I would defy anyone to pick up Sharks of the World - A Fully Illustrated Guide and not pause in wonder at any number of beasts swimming far off the beaten track: the yellow-striped Atlantic Weasel Shark, the abyssal Demon and Ghost Catsharks, the frankly ridiculous Winghead Shark, the hopelessly uncuddly Bramble Sharks. And that is long before one considers the over-sensationalised superstars such as the Whale Shark, Bull Shark, Tiger Shark and White Shark. 

 I cannot recommend this book highly enough so I won't. I can, however, wonder at how Wild Nature Press can follow this debut with a worthy successor. If they can make the fascinating this enthralling, perhaps they should set themselves a real challenge. Worms of the World, anyone?

Jeremy Stafford-Deitsch. 
Get it!

Friday, July 19, 2013

Sharks Count - Divers' Guide to Sharks!


Check this out!

I say, bravo Sam and Hannah!
This is an excellent complement to their Sharks Count project and having snooped a bit, the information provided is what a typical US-based citizen scientist will likely require - not too little and not too much!
And I did like the reference to the Fiji Bull Shark!

Vinaka!

Thursday, July 11, 2013

Is this a Spinner Shark?


From the Lautoka Fish market.
Click for plenty of detail!

To me, it looks like a common Blacktip.
I feel that I've seen this guy before, and the pinnae sure don't look breves to me!

BUT - does that anal fin have a black tip?
If so, brevis or not brevis, it is C. brevipinna as that's one of the principal diagnostic features differentiating it from C. limbatus, at least in the Caribbean where they are sympatric!
Or may it, gasp, be Jeremy's wayward tilstoni, see the description here???
Opinions?

And I'm still waiting for a correct answer to my last question!

Tuesday, July 09, 2013

Fiji: new Shark Record?

Pic by John Philp - click for detail.

Behold!

A surfer sent me this pic a few years ago.
It's from a surfing event in the mouth of the Sigatoka River, and the description that came with it was
Attached pic of one of the sharks from that contest in 2007 (May 5th) at the Sigatoka Riverrmouth, attached surfing pics show the clear water on the incoming tide then it becomes progressively brown with the outgoing tide and then the sharks appeared - predictably.

This was the same time I saw the sharks doing acrobatics in the river, maybe shedding remora's? I don't know. They really looked like dolphins playing. Bizzare.
You're going to think I'm delusional but I recall the sharks being about 4 or 5 feet long, and bizzarely they were spinning not only on their axis but also end over end forward like dolphins do, and they were not dolphins! I have to ask someone else who was there four years ago to see what they remember.
My first thought was Spinner Shark.
But having checked, they don't feature on the infamous Seeto list, and the IUCN doesn't list Fiji among its range - and so I opted for the common Blacktip that is both present here and also engages in leaping and spinning, this mostly when preying but possibly also in order to dislodge remoras.

But I may have been mistaken.
We've been recently engaged in a rather epic research project investigating Fiji's coastal Shark fishery, and I've just received the first DNA analyses of fin samples from the local Fish markets - and imagine my surprise at discovering an (undoubtedly correct) record of Carcharhinus brevipinna!

Regarding the Sigatoka, we'll of course never really know.
Both hypotheses are plausible - but my gut tells me that it was a Blacktip, this owing to the rather large black marking on the first dorsal as opposed to the rather inconspicuous one on the Spinner.
JSD? David?

Anyway, all very interesting!
This will undoubtedly lead to a publication, possibly lumped together with several other discoveries and range extensions we've recorded over the years.

Keep watching this space!

PS more evidence + a comment by John Philp here!

Sunday, April 14, 2013

New Shark Bible - get it!


And talking of Shark ID.

If you are interested in Sharks, you must get this.
Authored by the brilliant illustrator Marc Dando, by David Ebert, and by the indefatigable Sarah Fowler of inter alia the Shark Trust and the IUCN whose praise I could not possibly sing highly enough, it will be the most authoritative book on the different Shark species for many years to come - this obviously with the caveat that several taxa are under revision and that you must continue to keep abreast of the latest science about the topic.
The pre-publication offer for this book is now open, with special incentives for the first 500 orders received (free postage world-wide and a limited edition shark print of one of the original plates signed by the illustrator). 

Peep inside it here and order online. 
For those of you who know the 2005 Collins Field Guide to Sharks of the World (now out of print from Collins, but still available from Princeton Press): this book is completely new.
It is larger format, with 528 pages and nearly 60 new species illustrated, more detailed, and features photographs as well as Marc Dando’s stunning illustrations. You may think that it’s worth waiting for this book to be discounted on Amazon. Well, it is already discounted, and this offer is as good as it gets! 


Title: Sharks of the World - a fully illustrated guide 
Authors: David A. Ebert and Sarah Fowler
Illustrator: Marc Dando
Publication date: Summer 2013
ISBN: 978-0-9573946-0-5 
Amazon has a cheaper offer, however sans signed illustration.
Enjoy!