Showing posts with label Wikipedia. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Wikipedia. Show all posts

Sunday, January 08, 2012

Wikipedia - interesting!


Ha!
David reports that he has tried to edit the Shark fin soup article and that his revision has been instantly undone.
The history tab reveals this.
Very interesting!
I did some quick checking and it really appears that there's something going on here, with already one dedicated Facebook page and with at least one rather angry sinophile activist, one Clement Tan, using the Wikipedia link in order to corroborate his dislike of recent positive developments in Singapore.

Much ado about nothing?
Personally, I think this is rather alarming.
Wikipedia is clearly very much mainstream and perused by hundreds, if not thousands of people daily, and finding this kind of disinformation makes me doubt what I thought were the advantages of it being a wiki, i.e. a collaborative democratic source of information. I thought that there was some process whereby misleading information was being weeded out, but apparently this ain't so.

The Wikipedia piece is certainly cleverly worded.
It is true that even if one consults the the Red List, the vast majority of Sharks are technically not endangered, and it is probably also true that finning is not the principal reason for their demise.

But that's obviously just quote mining.
It remains true that the current extent of Shark fishing is completely unsustainable and that it poses a grave risk for marine ecosystems. And it also remains true that whereas many non-Asian nations fish for Sharks and partake in the Shark fin trade, much of the fishing is driven by the overwhelmingly Asian demand for Shark fins, and that those fins are being used to make the soup. And I certainly very much doubt that most sharks are caught in European nations!

The way I see it, it behooves us to rectify that article and to ensure that the facts are presented objectively.

Solutions?
I'm technically WAY out of my depth here - but is there some whiz kid that knows how to change a Wikipedia article and make those changes stick? Happy to intermediate contacts to somebody credible who can draft a proper wording - just write to the dive shop!

Saturday, January 07, 2012

Tu quoque Wikipedia?


From Wikipedia's Shark fin soup article, and I cite.

However, research has shown that the vast majority of shark species are gaining in population and not endangered;
CITES lists only 3 out of 400 species as needing protection.[8] Furthermore, shark finning contributes to a small proportion of sharks caught worldwide; most sharks are caught in European nations as bycatch, for sport, or for their meat. As a result, the movement against shark fins have been variously described as misled, reliant on populist rhetoric, or Sinophobic. [9]

Wow wow wow!!!
Yes the bad guys are fighting back!
Wikipedia is what I would consider a respected mainstream resource, and finding anti-Shark-conservation statements there is certainly alarming and very much an indicator that the Shark fin industry is feeling threatened and fighting back, and crafty to boot.
Does anybody know an editor there?

The above assertion is basically verbatim from an article in the Straight Times - you can find it here, together with comments by Shark advocates. It is of course total BS as CITES is certainly NOT a good indicator for whether a Shark is endangered.

The correct resource is of course the Red List.
There, several Sharks are listed as Threatened with Extinction, meaning either Critically Endangered, Endangered or Vulnerable.
Check it out - click for detail.

But most are not!
Out of approx. 400 species, I read that there are currently 41 sharks listed as vulnerable, 12 as endangered, and 15 as critically endangered (IUCN, 2011).
Yes many are Near Threatened (= not quite yet threatened) and it is important to invoke the precautionary principle - but then, let's do that and by doing so, we can also cover those Sharks that are Data Deficient and Not Evaluated!

And, the answer to Shark bycatch is not to keep the fins - it is to adopt bycatch mitigation measures that incidentally increase the number of target fish caught! And since the vast majority of by-caught Sharks are landed alive and would most certainly survive, the correct measure is to demand that they be released! To allow for the retention of bycatch and for the sale of the fins will simply mean that those live Sharks will be killed, and further encourage the targeted fishery for Sharks by the Tuna fleets, something that is already very much on the increase!
Details here!

Long story short?
Let's be vigilant because the bad guys are fighting back!
And, let's tell it as it is and not make things up!